Cleveland Cascades LtdTelestackCimbria Bulk Equipment A/SSailors SocietyCoaltrans MENA 2020Bühler GmbH
  • Cleveland Cascades Ltd
  • The Wolfson Centre for Bulk Solids Handling Technology
  • Port of Stockton
  • TBA Group
  • Cimbria Bulk Equipment A/S
  • Sailors Society

Prepare for coronavirus warns law firm

Prepare for coronavirus warns law firm

(Posted on 27/01/20)

The shipping industry needs to be prepared for potential restrictions in order to prevent the further spread of the ‘Wuhan’ coronavirus, advises a leading maritime law firm.

Preparation for potential escalation is needed advises Beth Bradley, a Partner with Hill Dickinson, who says that shipping should be prepared to face the same issues that arose in previous severe disease outbreaks, such as with other coronaviruses or Ebola, such as infection of crew members, quarantine measures, closure of ports, and possible repercussions on charterparty obligations. 

“While this outbreak is not currently anticipated to cause the global complications experienced by the Ebola and Sars outbreaks, it is wise for ship operators and charterers to be prepared for any greater spread of this virus,” she says.  Delays caused by quarantines and deviations have a different impact under charterparties. In relation to the safety of the crew, employers have a duty of care towards the crew under their employment contracts, and a breach of such a duty may lead to exposure to a variety of claims.

Under time charterparties, when a vessel is delayed by a quarantine or is forced to deviate due to an infected crew member, the vessel may be placed off-hire, subject to the wording of the charter. Common wordings of charterparties have been held to place the vessel off-hire due to legal or administrative restraints if they related to the efficiency or condition of the vessel or crew. In spite of this, should the delay be the inevitable result of orders resulting from how the charterers chose to employ the vessel, the vessel may remain on hire.

The outcome in each case will depend on the facts and the wording of the charterparty.  Under voyage charters, a deviation for the safety of the crew will be at the shipowner’s expense as no additional freight may be payable unless, under the Hague or Hague-Visby Rules, a “reasonable deviation” defence is successfully raised.  In order to commence laytime under a voyage charterparty, owners need to tender a valid Notice of Readiness (NOR).

For owners to do so, a vessel requires free pratique. Absent wording to the contrary in the charterparty, everyday practice provides that a Master can give a valid NOR without having first obtained free pratique, provided that there is no reason to assume that it is anything other than a mere formality. However, in cases of an outbreak, a vessel may be subject to quarantine delays, such that the assumption that the vessel will be able to obtain free pratique will not be a mere formality. If a vessel is calling or has called in an infected area, special protective measures may cause delays until the health of the crew is ascertained. The risk of such delays until a valid NOR is capable of being tendered is borne by the owner, unless the charterparty provides otherwise. 

Under a charterparty, charterers are under an obligation to nominate a safe port, an order with which the shipowners must comply with unless there is an unacceptable risk, or the port is known to be unsafe. Risks to the crew may render a port unsafe even where there is no risk of real damage to the vessel. Consequently, a contagious disease may legally make a port unsafe. 

The safety of a port depends greatly on whether proper precautions and protective measures are in place to ensure that a vessel can call at the port without risking infection of its crew. Such measures were taken during both the Ebola and MERS outbreaks, and numerous ports remained open despite being affected by the outbreak. 

At present, the Wuhan virus is not at a stage where it may render a port unsafe, and the severity of the outbreak would need to escalate significantly before owners could reasonably refuse to call at scheduled or nominated ports on the basis of the ports being unsafe. A standard force majeure clause suspends and/or terminates the contract on the occurrence of an extraordinary event beyond the parties’ reasonable control, which materially affects the parties’ ability to perform their contractual obligations. Such an occurrence should not reasonably have been foreseen or provided against. 

John Agapitos, Hill Dickinson paralegal, adds: At this time, there have only been internal transport bans affecting certain Chinese cities around the centre of the outbreak. There has not yet been a travel ban to China or any other neighbouring countries. It is unlikely that any given situation will fall within the scope of a force majeure clause, unless the wording of a particular clause is quite broadly drafted. However, if the outbreak escalates in the future and/or travel bans are imposed, questions of whether it amounts to a force majeure event may come to the fore." 

Latest News

MCTC issues coronavirus galley guide

(Posted on 18/02/20)

MCTC, the leading international catering and training provider, has issued guidance to galley crew who... Read more


NI survey finds automation pragmatism

(Posted on 18/02/20)

Automation and autonomous systems have been key, and sometimes controversial points in the debate over... Read more


EuroDry look to “sizable returns”

(Posted on 14/02/20)

EuroDry Ltd, an owner and operator of dry bulk vessels and provider of seaborne transportation for drybulk... Read more


Norvic names Fenger as COO

(Posted on 14/02/20)

Norvic Shipping has announced that its Board ofDirectors has appointed Michael Fenger as ChiefOperating... Read more


Damen unveils BWPF

(Posted on 13/02/20)

Damen Shipyards Group has unveiled a Ballast Water Pre Filtration Barge (BWPF) to assist vessels in... Read more


ClassNK grants AiP to Kawasaki

(Posted on 13/02/20)

Leading Classification Society ClassNK granted an Approval in Principle (AiP) based on its Rule Part... Read more


Survitec certified by DNV GL

(Posted on 13/02/20)

Survitec’s Marine Training Academy in Stonehaven, Scotland, has been certified as a recognised... Read more


Sulphur regs going smoothly, but plan ahead

(Posted on 02/02/20)

The transition to low sulphur fuels has so far been smooth, thanks to the efforts of shipping industry... Read more


Flowsafe’s crew health solution

(Posted on 02/02/20)

Flow Water Technologies has reported a marked increase in interest in its FlowSafe DCD 2000 Disinfectant... Read more


Bulker hybrid first for Wärtsilä

(Posted on 31/01/20)

The technology group Wärtsilä has been selected to provide the complete system design and... Read more


The Wolfson Centre for Bulk Solids Handling Technology Port of StocktonCoaltrans Poland 2020TOC EventsTBA GroupVigan
  • Coaltrans School of Coal Singapore 2020
  • Coaltrans MENA 2020
  • Port of Belledune
  • Bühler GmbH

Subscribe to our newsletter

Keep up to date with the latest global news in bulk cargo handling and shipping