Columbia: Compliance must be more than box-ticking exercise

(Posted on 11/08/25)

The International Maritime Organization’s Maritime Safety Committee (MSC) has sent a clear message: the ISM Code is overdue for serious reform.

The committee has called for a comprehensive overhaul of the guidelines governing safe ship management—guidelines that, despite their critical importance, no longer reflect the realities of life at sea, says Columbia Group.

This follows an independent IMO study that revealed just how inconsistently the ISM Code is enforced. The findings pointed to weak oversight, poor accountability, and a glaring disconnect between documented procedures and what crews actually experience, particularly in relation to fatigue, harassment, and excessive workloads, Columbia Group directors said.

Capt. Saurabh Mahesh, Group Director Crewing (Operations) at Columbia Group, believes this revision is long overdue. “There’s no question the Code needs to evolve. But it must go beyond simply redrafting language, it has to confront the reality that compliance is often little more than a box-ticking exercise,” he said. “We need to rebuild trust by ensuring real follow-up when breaches occur, and by guaranteeing that crews are genuinely protected, not just theoretically covered.”

The MSC’s recommendations include integrating anti-harassment measures into safety management systems, providing proper support for victims, protecting whistleblowers, and strengthening rest hour rules. But none of this will matter unless administrations and operators implement these reforms meaningfully—and are held accountable, says Columbia Group.

One of the most pressing issues is the falsification of rest hour records. Capt. Mahesh is among those calling for biometric solutions, fingerprint or retina scans, to replace outdated paper logs that are too easily manipulated. There are also calls for more rigorous external audits, realistic safe manning assessments that reflect vessel age and trading patterns, and decisive enforcement when non-conformities are uncovered. Without these changes, little will improve.

Working conditions themselves must be adapted to the complexity and pressure of modern shipping, Mr Mahesh added.

“One-size-fits-all shift patterns are no longer acceptable. Crews need flexible rest options, especially during extreme weather or congested port calls. Vessels operating on high-intensity routes should have access to shore-based officers who can provide relief. Greater use of digital tools, consistent crew feedback, and better engagement with shore services can all help ease the strain. These are practical solutions, they just require the will to put them in place.”

Latest News

Posidonia 2026 takes centre stage amid global freedom of navigation challenges

From insurance and risk management to energy transition, digitalisation and maritime security, the Posidonia... Read more

First maritime compliance & prevention-focused organisation, PaS, joins DBCE

Prevention at Sea (PaS), a leading maritime compliance, auditing, and digital solutions provider, has... Read more

NorthStandard reports strong results and strategic momentum

NorthStandard has reported strong financial results, continued strategic progress and enhanced support... Read more

Latest guidance for vessel transit through Strait of Hormuz

Hundreds of vessels remain unable to transit the Strait of Hormuz and, in the event of a return to more... Read more

The Bahamas regains QUALSHIP 21 eligibility

The Bahamas has regained eligibility for the United States Coast Guard’s QUALSHIP 21 programme... Read more

First dedicated STS standard for dry bulk released by INTERCARGO

Ship to ship (STS) transfers are an established part of dry bulk operations, and they are growing. As... Read more

Columbia reinforces commitment to maritime talent

Columbia Group has strengthened its commitment to developing the next generation of maritime professionals... Read more

Jamaica marks 50 years at IMO with call for island states to shape future

The Maritime Authority of Jamaica has marked Jamaica’s 50th anniversary as a member of the International... Read more

Costamare Bulkers logs first profit after Cargill deal removes most legacy trading

Costamare Bulkers Holdings Limited has reported unaudited financial results for the first quarter ended... Read more

NORDEN strengthens fleet with the addition of four Handysize vessels

NORDEN have announced that they have expanded their fleet with the purchase of four dry cargo Handysize... Read more