Aluminum associations’ letter to Trump

(Posted on 08/04/19)

The USA Aluminum Association has released a joint letter with the Aluminium Association of Canada and IMEDAL calling for the administration to reinstate quota-free exemptions from the aluminum tariffs for Canada and Mexico before the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) is implemented.

The full text of the letter is below:

To:

President Donald J. Trump, United States of America
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Canada
President Andrés Manuel López Obrador, Mexico

Dear Mr. President – 

On behalf of the North American aluminum industry, we encourage you to expeditiously resolve any national security concerns related to the Section 232 tariffs on aluminum products within North America and reinstate quota-free exemptions from the aluminum tariffs for Canada and Mexico before the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) is implemented. 

Our members benefit from robust, fair and rules-based trade of aluminum and aluminum products within North America. Fully resolving the Section 232 aluminum tariffs for Canada and Mexico, without quotas that would restrict our supply chains, will allow our countries to continue to invest in the aluminum industry. Together, the North American aluminum industry supports 852,000 direct and indirect jobs in our region. 

The new USMCA cannot work as intended without reinstating exemptions for Canada and Mexico from the 232 tariffs. The Section 232 tariffs are limiting access for North American aluminum producers to reach their suppliers and customers – and in some cases, their own subsidiaries and facilities. This will hamper continued investment for our industry, which has experienced solid growth and significant investment in recent years.

Replacing a tariff with a quota on aluminum imports in North America would be highly detrimental. If there is a quota system for aluminum trade within North America, it will be difficult to ensure that downstream manufacturers of aluminum products will have access to the aluminum inputs they need. Because primary aluminum is a traded commodity on the London Metals Exchange (LME), metal traders would be competing with mid- and downstream producers who need value-added primary aluminum with specific characteristics for their manufacturing processes. Additionally, semi-fabricated aluminum products can cross borders several times before final production. In a worst-case scenario, product could get stuck on one side of the border when the quota has been filled. To avoid shortages, companies may be forced to stockpile the metal, tying up capital that could be used to pay employees or upgrade equipment and exacerbating the impact of a quota system. 

The real problem facing the aluminum industry is the acute and persistent issue of illegally subsidized aluminum overcapacity from China, but tariffs or quotas against key trading partners and allies that operate as market economies do not address the China challenge and instead harm the overall competitiveness of the region – unfortunately, all to China’s benefit.

We were pleased to see the USCMA recognize our region’s common concerns about transshipment and the illegal evasion of duties, including provisions to promote increased cooperation and information sharing to address circumvention of trade remedy orders. This is an important priority for the aluminum industry as we ramp up collective trade enforcement activity across the region. The United States has successfully addressed unfairly subsidized imports of aluminum from China through its anti-dumping/countervailing duty (AD/CVD) investigations. Likewise, Mexico has initiated an AD/CVD case on aluminum foil imports from China. Canada recently moved to align its country of origin marking regime for steel and aluminum products to prevent transshipment and diversion of aluminum and steel. 

Our respective governments recognize the need to protect against transshipment and continue to pursue effective trade remedies and robust enforcement.  We believe that active monitoring and continued cooperation on this front will limit the ability of China to send unfairly subsidized aluminum into our shared market and address the national security concerns raised by the Section 232 on aluminum imports. We also stand ready to support our respective governments in addressing the fundamental problem of unfairly subsidized aluminum overcapacity in China.

We look forward to the resolution of the Section 232 aluminum tariffs and supporting USMCA implementation, because our aluminum producers need a reliable supply of primary aluminum and strong customer demand to fuel continued investment and hiring.  

Latest News

Rio Tinto reaches four billion tonnes of iron ore shipped to China

Rio Tinto has celebrates the shipment of four billion tonnes of iron ore from the Pilbara in Western... Read more

Africa’s opportunity to build sustainable logistics networks across mining sector

Capt. Pappu Sastry, CEO of Adhira Shipping and Logistics (ASL) has said that Africa’s mining sector... Read more

Conditions on Simandou iron ore investment now satisfied

All conditions have now been satisfied for Rio Tinto’s investment to develop the Simandou high... Read more

ADM offers segregated, traceable soybean meal to European customers

ADM, a global leader in innovative solutions from nature, has announced that it is offering fully verified... Read more

Rio Tinto to install carbon free aluminium smelting cells

Rio Tinto will install carbon free aluminium smelting cells at its Arvida smelter in Québec,... Read more

Moonbound appoints ASL for long-term South African lithium logistics project

Moonbound Mining Ltd. has appointed Adhira Shipping and Logistics (ASL) as its logistics contractor... Read more

ADM and Bayer collaboration help farmers achieve lower carbon emissions

 ADM and Bayer have announced an extension of their collaboration, working with farmers in a bid... Read more

US House appropriations bill includes reinstatement of NASS reports

A House appropriations subcommittee in the USA has approved its Fiscal Year 2025 bill that includes... Read more

Rio Tinto to acquire Mitsubishi’s stake in Boyne aluminium smelter

Rio Tinto has agreed to acquire Mitsubishi Corporation’s 11.65% interest in Boyne Smelters Ltd... Read more

Richards Bay Minerals’ renewable energy agreement

Richards Bay Minerals (RBM) has signed a renewable power purchase agreement (PPA) with Khangela Emoyeni... Read more