Port of StocktonCoaltrans MENA 2020TOC EventsCoaltrans School of Coal Singapore 2020ViganTBA Group
  • The Wolfson Centre for Bulk Solids Handling Technology
  • Cimbria Bulk Equipment A/S
  • Coaltrans School of Coal Singapore 2020
  • Coaltrans Poland 2020
  • TOC Events
  • Coaltrans MENA 2020

Water “most viable shaft lubricant”

Water “most viable shaft lubricant”

(Posted on 11/11/19)

Thordon Bearings is alerting its customers to the recent publication of a DNV GL study that concludes the recent surge in propeller shaft bearing failures is indeed related to the use of certain environmentally acceptable lubricants (EALs).

In conclusion to the first phase of an ongoing investigation, DNV GL reported that “there are transient conditions involving high oil film pressures and/or low oil temperatures where [synthetic] EALs will have a reduced load-carrying capacity. The vast majority of stern tube bearing failures in recent years occurred in the same type of transient conditions – during hard manoeuvring at high ship speeds, during mooring trials, and when operating with a partly submerged propeller”.

George Morrison, Regional Manager, EMEA – ANZ, Thordon Bearings, said: “While no ship operating a propeller shaft bearing lubricated by water – an EAL designated by the US Environmental Protection Agency – has been immobilized to date, there has been conjecture concerning the poor operational performance of some synthetic lubricants. It is now unequivocal: the performance of these EALs is less than satisfactory.”

The DNV GL report and a subsequent webinar, titled Environmentally Acceptable Sterntube Lubricants – How to Avoid Costly Failures, revealed a sharp increase in sterntube damage affecting all ship types and sizes following the 2014 introduction of rules prohibiting the use of mineral oil in oil-to-sea interfaces of vessels trading in US waters.

DNV GL found that the dominant failure was bearing wiping – when oil film is lost, resulting in metal to metal contact. It concluded that synthetic EALs behave differently than mineral oils under different operating pressures and temperatures, affecting viscosity and load bearing capacity. EALs based on unsaturated esters were singled out as being particularly prone to failure.

“This investigation verifies our long-held view that these EALs can impede shaft bearing and seal performance, damage critical components and compromise oil-tight integrity, resulting in emergency remedial repairs at significant cost to the shipowner,” added Morrison.

The investigation did not include seawater lubricated propeller shaft bearings because this arrangement falls under different class rules to those relating to sterntube bearings lubricated by mineral or synthetic oils.

“We have different rules covering seawater-lubricated bearings, and there is no problem to use those kind of designs for DNV GL classed ships [sic]. We did not see a necessity to include those in the same study,” said DNV GL in response to a written question put forward during the webinar.

The report’s findings are likely to send a ripple of concern throughout the industry given its investment in EAL oils, which were widely seen as a technically viable solution to reducing marine pollution from mineral oil-based lubricants.

Craig Carter, Director of Marketing & Customer Service, Thordon Bearings, said: “I would not be surprised if the classification societies start to revise their shaft alignment and withdrawal rules for bearings using this kind of lubricant. There is no doubt that lubricating white metal bearings with biodegradable oil can be technically and commercially risky. With mineral oil-based lubricants now rightly regarded as environmentally unacceptable, the only proven EAL option available for lubricating the propeller shaft bearing is seawater.”

Since 2014, DNV GL says it has noticed an increase in the number of ships adopting water lubricated propeller shaft bearing arrangements.

The classification society aims to continue the EAL study, investigating oil film thickness and thermal properties. A third phase of the investigation will look at mid-to long-term degradation, hydrolysis and wear rates of those seals and bearings using these types of lubricants.

Canada-based Thordon Bearings designs and manufactures a complete range of journal bearing and seal systems for marine, clean power generation, pump and other industrial markets.

Latest News

A first for Liebherr in the USA

(Posted on 18/02/20)

North Carolina Ports has opted for a new Liebherr portals lewing crane type LPS 420. Themulti purpose... Read more


Inmarsat’ new Saudi connectivity services

(Posted on 18/02/20)

Inmarsat, the world leader in global, mobile satellite communications, has announced that it will bring... Read more


Zero dust In Townsville

(Posted on 14/02/20)

The port of Townsville is booming with volumes metal concentrates. The Australian port is located near... Read more


Don’t forget fire-fighting

(Posted on 14/02/20)

Shipowners looking to retrofit marine exhaust gas cleaning systems as a way of complying with new sulphur... Read more


UWC certification for hopper cars

(Posted on 14/02/20)

Research and production corporation United Wagon Company (UWC), the largest producer of freight cars... Read more


AVEVA’s new design software

(Posted on 13/02/20)

AVEVA, global leader in engineering and industrial software, has announced an important update to its... Read more


3D printing revolution

(Posted on 13/02/20)

Online e-procurement portal for marine spares and equipment ShipParts.com is taking part in a project... Read more


Liebherr giant headed for China

(Posted on 02/02/20)

The LH 150 ET Gantry Port Litronic is not only the first electrically-operated port handling machine... Read more


New market for Ecolifting

(Posted on 31/01/20)

In the last quarter of 2019, Rhenus Logistics B.V. (Rhenus) ordered an eco-efficient Konecranes Gottwald... Read more


WinGD advances clean fuel research

(Posted on 31/01/20)

WinGD (Winterthur Gas & Diesel) has bolstered its investment in fuel research with the development... Read more


Coaltrans Poland 2020Port of BelleduneCleveland Cascades LtdThe Wolfson Centre for Bulk Solids Handling Technology Cimbria Bulk Equipment A/SBühler GmbH
  • Port of Stockton
  • Vigan
  • Bühler GmbH

Subscribe to our newsletter

Keep up to date with the latest global news in bulk cargo handling and shipping