Thordon concerns over VIDA changes

(Posted on 22/12/20)

Thordon Bearings has added to the growing concern over proposed changes to Vessel Incidental Discharge National Standards of Performance (VIDA) requirements, citing far reaching environmental consequences if clauses in the existing document are removed.

In a statement submitted to the United States Environmental Protection Agency on 20 November 2020, the Canada-based bearings and seals pioneer “strongly questions the removal of some text” in the proposed amendments, stating that such omissions will mean existing zero pollution solutions will be overlooked.

In the current Vessel General Permit (VGP 2013), the US EPA recommends that all newbuild vessel operators endeavor to use seawater-based systems for their stern tube lubrication to prevent the discharge of oil from these interfaces to the marine environment. But in the revised VIDA draft there is no mention of seawater as an Environmentally Acceptable Lubricant (EAL).

“It mentions composite bearings but does not state that the composite bearings must be lubricated by seawater to eliminate all risk of pollution,” said Craig Carter, Director of Marketing and Customer Service, Thordon Bearings.

Calling for a 60-day extension to the period in which stakeholders can comment on the proposals, Thordon states in the letter: “The omission of this text from the VIDA proposal minimizes the fact that a current in-use and proven zero pollution solution that has no impact on our seas and oceans is likely to be overlooked by vessel operators if it does not appear in the new VIDA.

“For vessel operators using seawater as a stern tube lubricant, there is absolutely zero impact on the ocean and sea environment, as there is no oil or synthetic EAL used. We firmly believe that the recommendation from the U.S. EPA stated in the VGP 2013, to use the only lubricant that has no impact on the environment and is currently in use in thousands of vessels, is an incredibly powerful statement to eliminate stern tube oil pollution from ships navigating US waters.

“Why would the EPA want to remove such a statement from the 2013 VGP that encourages new ships to be built using seawater lubrication, whereby the impact can eliminate this ship source of oil pollution forever? This omission from the Oil Management section would be deemed as going backward, rather than forward.”

The glaring omission is not the only issue with the proposed amendments. A major concern is the confusion surrounding air-type shaft seals.

On page 56 of the proposed draft, it states “during normal operation, small quantities of lubricant oil in these interfaces are released into surrounding waters.” But three pages later: “To the extent that these seals do not allow the lubricant to be released under normal circumstances they are not considered to be oil-to-sea interfaces.”

“These statements do not take into account seal failure resulting from rope or fishing lines becoming entangled around the propeller shaft. The aft seal damage can be severe, creating an oil-to-sea interface enabling synthetic lubricant/oil to flow freely out into the ocean. The confusion could also result in ship operators using mineral oil in an air seal, which is worse than an EAL discharge.”

Thordon also raises questions about the harmful impact that synthetic/vegetable EALs may have on aquatic life, suggesting that more research needs to be done on their environmental impact before their use can be approved as an EAL.

At the time of writing, www.regulations.gov, the US government website used for public commentary on new and existing regulations, had received 179 comments on the proposed VIDA amendments.

Latest News

Rio Tinto’s first Pilbara-made rail car built by Gemco in Karratha

Rio Tinto’s first Pilbara-made iron ore rail car has rolled off the production line in Karratha... Read more

Electric Liebherr portal crane strengthens Baria Serece, Vietnam

Precision meets progress at Phu My Port, Vietnam. The LPS 550 has been deployed to handle bulk commodities... Read more

bound4blue targets Asian growth with new production capabilities

bound4blue, a global leader in wind propulsion systems, has expanded its industrial footprint in Asia... Read more

DNV: Methanol as marine fuel at high readiness level

As the industry explores multiple decarbonisation pathways, methanol is gaining attention as a practical... Read more

Repeat Aasen bulk carrier order emphasises Wärtsilä hybrid strength

Technology group Wärtsilä will supply an integrated hybrid propulsion system for a bulk carrier... Read more

Superior bring big iron and bigger ideas

Superior Industries, Inc., a US-based manufacturer and global supplier of bulk material processing and... Read more

ESL connectivity upgrade enables smarter operations and supports crew wellbeing

ESL Shipping has taken a significant step forward in digitalisation by deploying a new multichannel... Read more

Junma partnership results in expansion and new orders for CMT

Condition Monitoring Technologies (CMT) has deepened its presence across Asia’s most influential... Read more

Contract signed for world’s largest battery-powered bulk carrier

After delivering its first full-scale seagoing project last week, Wattlab signed a contract at Europort... Read more

New Steelpaint contract with Germany’s inland waterways

Steelpaint GmbH has reported strong growth in orders for corrosion protection coatings on Germany&rsquo... Read more