Geneva DryViganTBA GroupVan AalstPort of StocktonSailors Society
  • Port of Stockton
  • Sailors Society
  • Van Aalst
  • Cimbria
  • Port of South Louisiana
  • TBA Group

ESPO calls for scope to avoid carbon and business leakage

ESPO calls for scope to avoid carbon and business leakage

(Posted on 28/01/22)

The European Sea Ports Organisation (ESPO) has welcomed the proposal to include shipping in an Emission Trading System (ETS). Putting a price tag on shipping emissions through the EU ETS should deliver clear climate gains and push the sector to choose greener solutions. However, the effectiveness of this policy will be undermined if evasion of a regional ETS is possible through rerouting of business.

Given the international character of shipping, a global market-based measure would be, by far, the most suitable option. Such a global measure would be more difficult to evade, and would entail lower risks for negative competitiveness effects compared to a regional measure. ESPO therefore asks the European Union to increase the pressure on the International Maritime Organization (IMO) to make progress on the development of such a global market-based measure. An alignment between the EU ETS and a market-based measure on the international level should then follow.

The Commission proposal for a European maritime ETS covers the emissions from intra-EU voyages and emissions at berth, alongside half of the emissions from extra-EU voyages (both incoming and outgoing voyages). Due to the limited scope of the current ETS proposal, ships can find ways to avoid falling in the scope of the EU ETS, by rerouting and calling, where possible, at non-EU neighbouring ports in order to minimise costs.

Evasive port calls at neighbouring non-EU ports could seriously jeopardise the effectiveness of the maritime ETS, as it would not reduce total shipping emissions. It could even increase overall emissions, in particular when evasion leads to longer voyages.

At the same time, evasive calls would divert traffic and business from European ports and seriously impact the business of certain important European ports which are already in fierce competition with other ports in countries neighbouring the EU. This risk exists for ports in the EU located in the North Sea, the Baltic Sea, the Mediterranean Sea and the Black Sea. Many of the affected ports are important nodes in the EU logistic chains, and play a crucial role in their regional economies.

For Europe’s ports the monitoring clause in the Commission proposal is too little too late. Instead of measuring the damage once it is already done, ESPO asks first for a full impact assessment of the implications of the current geographical scope of the proposal on carbon and business leakage, along with the accumulated impact of all Fit for 55-proposals. ESPO is happy to share evidence of the impact with EU policymakers in order to find an appropriate solution.

“European ports are supportive of an emission trading scheme and see pricing as an excellent instrument to boost greener behaviour. However, the Commission proposal contains too many loopholes that risk to seriously harm Europe’s ports business without any gains in emission reduction from maritime, on the contrary. Ships can move, ports cannot. The polluter will not pay, but move out where possible, without any emission gains. We cannot just wait and monitor the damage that would result from the current proposal. Decisive action must be taken by the Commission, Parliament and Council to prevent the risk of evasive port calls and delocalisation of port activities outside the EU and the negative impact on Europe’s connectivity,” says Isabelle Ryckbost, ESPO Secretary General.

A possible solution – if legally possible – could be to expand the scope of the proposal by considering the evasive call to/from a non-EU neighbouring port as a call to an EU port in the counting of the ETS emissions. In addition, the proposed monitoring mechanism should be strengthened to clearly define evasive trends, and foresee next steps if such trends are identified.

Latest News

Tunley Environmental announces ambitious transatlantic expansion plans

(Posted on 19/06/24)

Sustainability consultancy Tunley Environmental is announcing ambitious transatlantic expansion plans... Read more


Duluth earns favourable marks in Green Marine environmental rating

(Posted on 14/06/24)

The Duluth Seaway Port Authority and its terminal operations on Rice’s Point ranked among the... Read more


Humber Freeport makes new home in historic trade centre

(Posted on 07/06/24)

Associated British Ports (ABP) has announced that the Humber Freeport Company has located its headquarters... Read more


Partnership for Lake Ontario short sea shipping corridor with USA

(Posted on 07/06/24)

The Hamilton Oshawa Port Authority (HOPA Ports) has announced an agreement with an affiliate of Beowulf... Read more


Stockholm and Baltic ports seek funds for Ukrainian cooperation

(Posted on 01/06/24)

Ports of Stockholm, together with Odessa headquartered law firm Interlegal and the Baltic Ports Organization... Read more


German and Lithuanian ports working together

(Posted on 31/05/24)

Co-operation in the maritime industry between Lithuania and Germany continues to grow. This is one of... Read more


New collaboration on Flemish seaport circular economy impact

(Posted on 28/05/24)

The Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB) has launches a new chair in collaboration with Circular Flanders... Read more


AD Ports launches Maritime Sustainability Research Centre

(Posted on 28/05/24)

AD Ports Group, a leading facilitator of global trade, logistics and industry, based in Abu Dhabi, has... Read more


250 hectares available for new industrial activities on HAROPA Port land

(Posted on 22/05/24)

The “France 2030 Turnkey Sites” scheme announced in May 2023 by the French government has... Read more


AD Ports to develop Chittagong Port

(Posted on 22/05/24)

AD Ports Group, a leading facilitator of global trade, logistics and industry, has signed a MoU with... Read more


CimbriaBühler GmbHPort of South LouisianaTelestackTMS Awards 2023
  • Geneva Dry
  • TMS Awards 2023
  • Telestack
  • Vigan
  • Bühler GmbH

Subscribe to our newsletter

Keep up to date with the latest global news in bulk cargo handling and shipping